University Will Investigate Christian Professor’s Intelligent Design Class Following Atheist Furor
Ball State University, a public
institution in Muncie, Indiana, is purportedly looking into claims that a
course centered around the subjects of creationism and intelligent
design constitutes a violation of the separation of church and state.
The college purportedly began its investigation after the Freedom From
Religion Foundation (FFRF), a church-state separatist group, sent a
letter of complaint regarding physics and astronomy professor Eric
Hedin.
Hedin’s offense? He apparently
encourages students to read books by scientists, journalists and
proponents who embrace intelligent design. The description of his
course, as reported by
World on Campus, claims that students will “investigate physical
reality and the boundaries of science for any hidden wisdom within this
reality which may illuminate the central questions of the purpose of our
existence and the meaning of life.”
Screen shot from the Ball State University website
While the course, “Inquiries in Physical Sciences,” is an elective, that hasn’t stopped critics like University of Chicago professor Jerry Coyne, in addition to the FFRF, from speaking out against it
as an alleged violation of the separation of church and state. In
addition to sharing pages from the course syllabus on his blog, he wrote:
Note the numinous implications, especially the course objective to consider the implications of physics, life, and consciousness for “indications of the nature and existence of God.” As you’ll see, the syllabus is clearly slanted to show that scientific phenomena do indeed provide evidence for God.
Note that on page 2 (below), the course outline itself, the students are to discuss theistic evolution, intelligent design, irreducible complexity, and, for crying out loud, “miracles and spirituality!” There’s also “Beauty, complex and specified information, and intelligent design: what the universe communicates about God.”
Not everyone agrees with Coyne, though.
Despite having negative comments to throw Hedin’s way (he called him a
“dingbat professor”), PZ Myers, a biologist at the University of
Minnesota who is also an atheist, defended the professor’s right to tout
and explore unpopular ideas in the classroom. After all, isn’t that
what academic freedom is all about?
“Academic freedom is the issue here,
and professors have to have the right to teach unpopular, controversial
issues, even from an ignorant perspective,” Myers wrote,
going on to place the course — and the situation — in context. “The
first amendment does not apply; this is not a course students are
required to take, and it’s at a university, which students are not
required to attend. It’s completely different from a public primary or
secondary school. A bad course is an ethical problem, not a legal one.
It’s also an issue that the university has to handle internally.”
The FFRF, though, an atheist-activist mouthpiece, is siding more with Coyne’s camp, as the group’s letter
sparked an investigation by school administrators — an inquiry that was
launched just one day after the atheist group’s letter of complaint was
received. While the university did not cite Hedin’s name in its
response, it was clear who was being referred to.
“The university received a complaint
from a third party late yesterday afternoon about content in a specific
course offered at Ball State. We take academic rigor and academic
integrity very seriously,” read an official response
from Ball State. “Having just received these concerns, it is impossible
to comment on them at this point. We will explore in depth the issues
and concerns raised and take the appropriate actions through our
established processes and procedures.”
What do you think about the debate — and the university’s response? Let us know in the comments section.
(H/T: World on Campus)
–
Other Must Read Stories:
- ‘Bigoted, Religious [Zealots]‘: High School Senior Allegedly Expelled, Charged With Felonies Over Gay Relationship With ‘Consenting’ Fellow Student
- Did Christian Prayers at Gov’t Meetings in This NY Town Violate the Constitution?
- ‘Pedophile Protection’: Rapist Takes Young Girl to Planned Parenthood for an Abortion to Hide His Crime
Comments
Post a Comment